N. 52
Doctrine
(A) National
1. Brief considerations on the prohibition of contradictory behavior in the
arbitration proceedings
Daniel Siqueira Borda and Danyara Barros Tajra…………………………………………………………. 7
2. Theories of international arbitration and related practical issues: the Brazilian
approach (particularly the recent leading case on recognition of annulled awards)
vis-à-vis the “delocalization trend”
Antonio Carlos Nachif Correia Filho……………………………………………………………………… 26
(B) International
1. Arbitration in European Union law
Manuel Pereira Barrocas……………………………………………………………………………………… 55
2. The détachement of international arbitration: reflections on the existence of an
arbitral order détaché
Raquel Macedo Moreira……………………………………………………………………………………… 68
3. Claims between defendants in arbitration: notes on recent developments from
Portuguese law
Matilde Líbano Monteiro…………………………………………………………………………………….. 86
Case law
(A) National State Commentary
1. Doubt about the dispute resolution method chosen by the parties. Arbitration
or arbitration. Contract entered into before the 1996 Arbitration Law.
Explicit or implicit consent. Analysis of the factual and business context.
Arbitration clause in separate document. Superior Court of Justice.
4th Panel. Special Appeal No. 1.569.422/RJ. Reporting Justice Marco
Aurélio Belizze. J. 26.04.2016. Doubt regarding the dispute resolution method.
Arbitration or pricing evaluation. Signing of the contract before the Brazilian
Arbitration Act of 1996. Explicit or implicit consent. Analysis of the negotial
and factual context. Arbitration agreement in a separate document. Superior
Court of Justice. Special Appeal No. 1.569.422/RJ. Reporter Minister Marco
Aurélio Belizze. Judgment of 26.04.2016
Christian Sahb Batista Lopes and Lucas Sávio Oliveira da Silva…………………………………… 101
2. Enforcement of extrajudicial title with arbitration clause. Limitation of the
object of execution motions in state courts. Superior Court of Justice.
4th Panel. Reporting Justice Luis Felipe Salomão. Special Appeal No. 1.465.535/SP.
J. 21.06.2016. Enforcement proceeding. Arbitration clause within the contract to
be enforced. Debtor’s motion to stay execution in court. Restriction on the issues
to be heard by the court. Superior Court of Justice. Special Appeal No. 1.465.535/SP.
Reporter Minister Luis Felipe Salomão. J. 21.06.2016
Flávio Spaccaquerche Barbosa and Leonardo de Castro Coelho………………………………….. 155
(B) International State Commentary
1. Action for annulment. Irregular constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal. The role of the
secretary and assistants of the Arbitral Tribunal. Switzerland. Federal Court.
DFT 4A_709/2014, of May 21, 2015. Setting aside proceedings. Irregular
constitution of the arbitral tribunal. Role of secretaries and consultants to the
arbitral tribunal. Switzerland. Federal Court. DFT 4A_709/2014 of May 21, 2015
Jean Marguerat and Tomás Navarro Blakemore…………………………………………………………194
2. Commercial arbitration. Annulment of arbitral award. Duty to disclose the
arbitrator and the party’s duty to seek easily accessible information. Preclusion of
the arbitrator’s right to challenge. Decision of the Court of Cassation
upheld the decision handed down by the Paris Court of Appeal on October 29, 2013.
Commercial arbitration. Annulment of the arbitral award. Duty of disclosure
of the arbitrator and duty of the parties to seek for easy access information.
Right to challenge the arbitrator precluded. Decision of the cour de cassation
that upheld the decision of the cour d’appel of Paris in 29.10.2013
Carlos Eduardo Stefen Elias and Raquel Macedo Moreira…………………………………………….206
General Information
1. Sixth Session of the Paris Arbitration Academy – 2016
Claudia Battagin, Elora Farias, Giulia Bonadio, Juliana Felippe, Klaus Rilke and
Luciana Rebeschini……………………………………………………………………………………………..224
2. Brazil Joins the Discussion About Gender (in)Equality in International Arbitration
Flavia Foz Mange………………………………………………………………………………………………. 229
Classics of Arbitration
1. Introductory note to the article “Perspectives on Commercial Arbitration in Brazil”,
by José Carlos Magalhães
Leonardo Furtado………………………………………………………………………………………………. 239
Book Reviews
1. Arbitration Law
Author: Jean-Baptiste Racine
Bruno Guandalini………………………………………………………………………………………………. 250
Magazine of Magazines
1. Ana Paula Montans…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 253
Editorial Line……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..263