N. 54
Doctrine
(A) National
1. Arbitration, arbitrage and dispute boards: the role of the third party in determining
the price of a stock option
Francisco Paulo de Crescenzo Marino…………………………………………………………………….. 7
2. Points of intersection between arbitration and the Judiciary: an analysis of the
judgments of the stj and the tjsp private law chambers in 2016
Ana Olivia Antunes Haddad, André Luís Bergamaschi and Livia Maria de Souza Crepaldi… 28
3. Myths, beliefs and the paradigm shift in arbitration with the public administration
administration
Thiago Luís Sombra…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 54
(B) International
1. Due process paranoia and the procedural judgment rule: a safe harbor for
procedural management decisions by international arbitrators
Klaus Peter Berger and J. Ole Jensen………………………………………………………………………… 73
Case law
(A) National State Commentary
1. Limited company. Partial dissolution. Arbitration clause not
recognized. Judicial determination of assets. TJSP. Appeal
nº 1001480-41.2015.8.26.0011. Rel. Carlos Alberto Garbi. J. 28.11.2016.
Limited liability company. Partial liquidation. Arbitration clause not recognized.
Valuation of assets to take place in court. São Paulo Court of Appeal. Appeal
nº 1001480-41.2015.8.26.0011. Judge Carlos Alberto Garbi. J. 28.11.2016
Renato Berger……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 95
2. Arbitration clause. Enforcement action. Judiciary. Existence of arbitration
clause. Arbitration proceedings initiated. Merits of the objections to enforcement
and third-party claims brought in arbitration. Conflict of jurisdiction between
state jurisdiction and arbitral jurisdiction. Stj. Suspension of enforcement to await
the arbitration decision. Jurisdiction-competence principle. Arbitration
clause. Debt enforcement procedure. State courts. Existence of arbitration clause.
Requirement of arbitration. Discussion of the arbitration merits at the motion to
stay debt enforcement procedure. Suspension of the debt enforcement procedure
awaiting arbitration decision. Competence-competence
Thiago Rodovalho…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 107
3. Vienna Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods
goods (cisg). Applicable rule of substantive law. Chicken feet case.
Failure to deliver the goods. Essential breach. Total termination of the contract.
Application of the unidroit principles and the principle of objective good faith. Restitution
of the price and compensation. TJRS. 12th Civil Chamber. Civil Appeal No. 70072362940.
Rel. Humberto Sudbrack. J. 14.02.2017. Vienna Convention on Contracts
for International Sales of Goods (cisg). Applicable rules of substantive law. Chicken
feet case. Lack of delivery of goods. Fundamental breach. Avoidance of the contract.
Application of the unidroit Principles and the principle of objective good faith.
Payment restitution and damages. Rio Grande do Sul Court of Appeal. 12th civil
chamber. Appeal nº 70072362940. Judge Humberto Sudbrack. J. 14.02.2017
Fernando Kuyven and Francisco Pignatta………………………………………………………………… 119
(B) International State Commentary
1. Res judicata in arbitral awards. Effects limited to the operative part. No
applicable to the grounds. Public procedural order not violated.
Arbitral award upheld. A.____ Llp v. B.____, Swiss Federal Court,
First Civil Chamber, judgment 4a_633/2014 of 29.05.2014. Res judicata
of arbitral awards. Effects limited to the conclusions of the award. Non-applicability
to the underlying reasoning. Procedural public policy not violated.
Arbitral award upheld. A.____ Llp v. B.____, Swiss federal tribunal,
first civil law chamber, judgment 4a_633/2014 of 29.05.2014
Leonardo Augusto dos Santos Lusvarghi………………………………………………………………. 155
General Information
1. Arbitration in the energy sector: the highlights of the 4th annual conference on
international arbitration in the energy sector
Michelle T. Grando…………………………………………………………………………………………… 175
2. Report on the VIII Congress on International Commercial Arbitration – ICC Costa
Rica 2017
Christian Díaz Barcia, Dyalá Jimenéz Figueres and Herman Duarte Iraheta…………………. 182
3. Inovarb launch event: “The first arbitration as an arbitrator –
Path and challenges”
Ligia Ferreira Novais de Oliveira………………………………………………………………………… 189
4. Cost control in arbitration – Third party funding and expedite procedure
Mariana Aguieiras Cuozzo…………………………………………………………………………………. 192
5. Arbitration in corporate law
Mariana Cattel Alves and Luiza Pedroso………………………………………………………………….. 199
Classics of Arbitration
1. Introductory note to the article “The new Lex Mercatoria: The first twenty-five
years”, by Michael Mustill
Stavros Brekoulakis…………………………………………………………………………………………… 203
Book Reviews
1 The idea of arbitration
Author: Jan Paulsson
Ana Gerdau de Borja………………………………………………………………………………………… 238
2. Arbitration in the electricity sector
Author: Diogo Albaneze Gomes Ribeiro
Rafael Villar Gagliardi………………………………………………………………………………………. 241
Journal of Journals
1. Ana Paula Montans…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 246
Editorial Line……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..256